Time Runs Out for Transplant Teen
Time Runs Out for Transplant Teen
Nataline Sarkisyan, a 17-year-old from Glendale, Calif., died Thursday just a few hours after her insurer, Cigna Health Care, approved a procedure it had previously described as "too experimental". They had originally agreed to a transplant but then changed their minds when the accountants felt they knew more medicine than the doctors. picked by 2manyusernames 10 months ago
tags sarkisyan teenager liver transplant insurance
452
 quote edit #1 
  comments (13)  share edit history (2)
< 1 >
5
 leehblan...
10 months ago
Anyone that can put a price on a life, or arbitrarily decide that a procedure is "too risky (financially?) should rot in hell! Are you listening, Cigna?
167
quote #2
6
 topofall
10 months ago
Well I hope they are very pleased with themselves and how much they have saved the company!
75
quote #3
9
 Killerbe...
10 months ago
All insurance companies have a deal with the devil!
84
quote #4
8
 teresag
10 months ago
Hooray to the nurses for speaking up! Unfortunately, too late to help her.
Condolences for her grieving family members.
Maybe they will find comfort knowing that this case will change the status quo (as I hope it will.)
84
quote #5
About Plime
Plime is an editable wiki community where users can add and edit weird and interesting links. Users earn karma when other users vote on their actions. The more karma you have, the more power you have at Plime.
20
 Alton
10 months ago
Here's the salary and other information about the insurance company, Cigna's CEO H Edward Hanway.

Last year his bonus was $3 million. His total compensation for the 2006 was $28.82 million. I wonder how much denying this girl will bump his bonus up this year.
93
quote #6
7
 tragluk
10 months ago
I don't like the insurance companies either but there are some more facts in this case that are buried.

Fact 1: Cigna didn't take her off life support and say "She's in Gods hands." Her parents did.

Fact 2: Cigna APPROVED the procedure until the girl got sick with a lung complication.

Fact 3: The Doctors had a liver they could have given her, the Doctors (hospital) had the expertise. The HOSPITAL didn't do it until Cigna said that they'd pony up the money.

Parents Fault? Hospital's Fault? Nooo.. Can't be the grieving (and litigous) parents. Can't be the doctor who is going out and playing golf this Friday after waiting on someone to foot the bill before he'd operate. Nope. Has to be the 'faceless' people with the money that is at fault.

I don't like health insurer's, but for every operation that they don't approve that's money for another operation that they can. Only so much money is there and if they approve 10 million dollar operations for 90 year old people who are probably going to die anyways, where is the 1 million dollar operation for a 2 year old? It's a horrid job but a final line needs to be drawn when there are only so many funds and too many people asking for them.

In the end, my personal blame is on the hospital. How can they sit there with a patient in their room, a liver from a donar, and simply say 'No. Your insurance hasn't approved the check yet, you're gonna die.'
132
quote #7
24
 imnotyoo
10 months ago
That's f**ked up.
37
quote #8
26
 Moe
10 months ago
Regardless if it was the insurance people or the hospital people, the poor girl died because some c*cks*cking pencil pusher valued the bottom line more than her life and that is f*cking sinful. If it was THEIR KID, you can bet your ass the chips would have fallen differently.

I hope whomever is at the root of this bullsh*t has nightmares about her every night for the rest of their life.
84
quote #9
19
 Maven
10 months ago
She had a 60% chance of living 6 MONTHS with the new liver.

Sorry, but I'm pretty sure they could have kept her alive for 6 months without the machines, too.
64
quote #10
30
 Bornbad
10 months ago
I've been following this story for weeks. If she had lived only one more day that would have made it worthwhile. We spend billions on war against the "Axis of Evil". Why not spend a few dollars on our own?
106
quote #11
5
 leehblan...
10 months ago
« Bornbad : I've been following this story for weeks. If she had lived only one more day that would have made it worthwhile. We spend billions on war against the "Axis of Evil". Why not spend a few dollars on our own?
Watch yourself. Under the current administration, this is a traitorous statement. Money is God, we are an "attractive nuisance"
103
quote #12
8
 teresag
10 months ago
« tragluk : I don't like the insurance companies either but there are some more facts in this case that are buried.

Fact 1: Cigna didn't take her off life support and say "She's in Gods hands." Her parents did.

Fact 2: Cigna APPROVED the procedure until the girl got sick with a lung complication.

Fact 3: The Doctors had a liver they could have given her, the Doctors (hospital) had the expertise. The HOSPITAL didn't do it until Cigna said that they'd pony up the money.

Parents Fault? Hospital's Fault? Nooo.. Can't be the grieving (and litigous) parents. Can't be the doctor who is going out and playing golf this Friday after waiting on someone to foot the bill before he'd operate. Nope. Has to be the 'faceless' people with the money that is at fault.

I don't like health insurer's, but for every operation that they don't approve that's money for another operation that they can. Only so much money is there and if they approve 10 million dollar operations for 90 year old people who are probably going to die anyways, where is the 1 million dollar operation for a 2 year old? It's a horrid job but a final line needs to be drawn when there are only so many funds and too many people asking for them.

In the end, my personal blame is on the hospital. How can they sit there with a patient in their room, a liver from a donar, and simply say 'No. Your insurance hasn't approved the check yet, you're gonna die.'
I agree. Let's not even mention the people who could be spared hospitalizations, disability and injuries if we only provided prevention, not after-the-fact treatment.
0
quote #13
6
 diana
10 months ago
So, nationalized health care is not an option why? Loss of money for the medical providers, hospitals, and drug companies?
0
quote #14
+ add a comment
< 1 >

copyright Worth1000, LLC